
IT'SUGAR Chose Its First 3PL From 10 Candidates and Grew DTC From Zero to 4,000 Orders a Month
A candy retailer with about 110 stores had never used a 3PL and was drop-shipping everything to its stores. 3PL Bridge helped it compare 10 operators, solve food-grade and temperature requirements, and launch an ecommerce channel that grew to 4,000 orders a month.
At a glance
- Company
- IT'SUGAR, candy and novelty retail (about 110 stores)
- Before
- No 3PL; vendors drop-shipped directly to stores
- Requirements
- Food-grade, FDA-registered space; temperature control for chocolate; SQF Level 3 for wholesale
- Channels
- Store replenishment, wholesale and a new DTC channel
- Region
- Chicago area (Illinois, Indiana and Atlanta priced)
- Timeline
- March to September 2025, intake to signed contract
By the numbers
Background
IT'SUGAR is a candy and novelty retailer with about 110 stores across the United States, plus locations in Canada and Hawaii. Until 2025 it had never worked with a 3PL. Product was drop-shipped straight to stores, which meant heavy parcel spend and very little visibility into inventory or flow.
The challenge
The team needed a central warehouse that could restock stores, support wholesale customers and launch a direct-to-consumer channel, in that order, without ever having run a 3PL relationship before. The plan was phased: novelty items such as plush, mugs and apparel first, candy second.
Candy made the requirements strict. The facility had to be food-grade and FDA-registered, some wholesale customers required SQF Level 3 certification, and chocolate had to stay below 78°F, with extra temperature-controlled staging needed about three months a year. Ecommerce volume was expected at 4,000 to 6,000 orders a month, with spikes of 8,000 to 10,000 around Christmas and Valentine's Day.
What mattered most: IT'SUGAR's Decision-Making Criteria
Every 3PL Bridge evaluation starts by turning the team's pain points into weighted Decision-Making Criteria. Operators are then qualified and compared against those criteria, not against a generic checklist. These are the criteria that shaped IT'SUGAR's decision.
| Criterion | What it meant for this brand | Importance |
|---|---|---|
| Food-grade compliance | FDA-registered, food-grade space and a path to SQF Level 3. | 5/5 |
| Temperature control for chocolate | Chocolate held below 78°F, with seasonal temperature-controlled staging. | 5/5 |
| Transparent pricing | Every line on a sample invoice tied to a real service. | 5/5 |
| Store replenishment and wholesale | Parcel and LTL to 110 stores plus wholesale pallet staging. | 4/5 |
| DTC launch readiness | Shopify integration and capacity for holiday spikes. | 4/5 |
| Onboarding support | Help building processes for a team new to 3PLs. | 4/5 |
| Central location | Reach to stores nationwide at a competitive cost. | 3/5 |
Importance on a 1 to 5 scale, where 5 could decide the outcome on its own.
How the evaluation worked
We scoped all three channels, then gathered pricing from operators in Illinois, Indiana and Atlanta while IT'SUGAR weighed about 10 candidates in total. Rates were reworked into a tiered structure the brand could compare cleanly, including all-in pallet build pricing for store shipments and parcel rates by zone.
When the leading operator's pro-forma invoice showed a line of about $40,000 that the team could not tie to a specific service, it went back for explanation before anything was signed. The brand's legal team worked through SLAs and certifications, and the president, merchandising, business strategy and technology leaders toured the Chicago-area facility before final approval from the parent company. The contract was signed in September 2025, with Shopify connected through APIs for real-time orders, tracking and inventory sync.
The result
Stores stayed stocked from a central, food-grade operation, and the new DTC channel grew from zero to 4,000 orders a month.
What other brands can take from this
- If you have never used a 3PL, pick a partner that will help build your processes, not just store your product.
- Ask for a sample invoice on a real order and make every line explain itself before you sign.
- For food and confectionery, confirm certifications and temperature limits in writing. They are pass/fail, not nice-to-haves.
Questions brands ask
- What does a candy brand need from a 3PL?
- At a minimum a food-grade, FDA-registered facility, temperature control for chocolate and, for some wholesale customers, SQF certification. IT'SUGAR required all three and chocolate held below 78°F.
- How many 3PLs should a brand compare?
- Enough to see real price and capability differences. IT'SUGAR weighed about 10 operators, with pricing gathered in Illinois, Indiana and Atlanta, before choosing a Chicago-area partner.
Want the same analysis for your operation?
A Brand Advisor turns your team's priorities into Decision-Making Criteria, qualifies operators from our network of 350+ 3PLs and puts every quote on the same basis. You choose who to meet and who to sign with. There is no cost to brands.
Talk to a Brand AdvisorSee 3PL pricing by marketMore case studies
Written by 3PL Bridge with IT'SUGAR's approval. Operator names are kept private. Published November 2026.
